Talk:Jay/@comment-43407464-20190812052505/@comment-43407464-20200603025153

@Shadowhunterschroniclesfans123 While I agree in certain points, since we don't know his mother and there is a chance that Jafar could be just an "adopted" father, I don't agree with why though. You are saying it would make sense for him to be the child of Aladin and Jasmine because of how easily he accepted the "good" lifestyle which is the complete opposite message of what Mellisa De La Cruz was trying to send. Her message was that you cannot judge others because of what their parents did. Also it isn't the genes that is wrong, but the environment the children were raised. Your reasoning makes it seem that because he is the child of the protagonist rather than the antagonist, he is inherently good. Good and bad isn't really based on genes, unless you know they turn out to be a psycopath and it's just a mutation that caused it. Otherwise, generally, a chlid is the result of their environment. Aladin didn't steal because he was inherently bad, we saw that. He had a large heart but he had to eat (Gotta eat to live, gotta steal to eat). Jay lived a life similar if not worse than Aladin. He lived on an island that was blocked off, only recieved trash, and was full of bad people. You had to learn to fight, to defend, to steal. The children didn't want that, they grew up in that. You saw Dizzy, she was the granddaughter of Lady Treamine, yet she was a sweet child. She went through both a grandmother and a mother who were evil. She, unlike most, was surrounded by evil, by both her aunt, mother and grandmother. I do think that there is a chance that he is a child of at least one of the protagonists, Aladin or Jasmine, due to the title of Jay of Agrabah, but not due to his stance on good or bad.